2nd Sunday of
Easter
Fr. Philip Neri Powell OP
St. Albert the Great,
Irving
Thomas,
called Didymus, has a problem. It's problem just about every
Christian or potential Christian who's lived since the Resurrection
has encountered. We can call this problem Doubt. Or, better yet,
Denial: “I will not believe until I have physical, verifiable
evidence.” Generally, this is a problem about believing the
supernatural claims of the faith: the virgin birth, various miracles
– healings, water to wine, raising the dead –, casting out
demons, the Resurrection, etc. More specifically, in the case of
Thomas, it's a problem about believing that his fellow disciples have
seen the Risen Lord in the flesh post-Resurrection. Thomas does not
believe that the other disciples actually witnessed Christ appear
among them. He not only doesn't believe them, he also flatly says, “I
will not believe until I put hands into his wounds.” We can imagine
the reactions of the other disciples. Are we that untrustworthy?
Is he accusing us of lying? Maybe he thinks we're delusional!
Whatever they may have thought about Thomas' denial of their witness,
Thomas himself is adamant: I will not believe!
Taking his denial at face value, Thomas is the first modern Man. How
do we respond to the Thomases we encounter every day?
Now,
it could be that Thomas is overcome by grief. Or anger. His
disbelief, at this stage of mourning, could be a response to losing
his teacher and friend. He wasn't there for the revelation of Christ
in the flesh. His outburst is just an overly emotional reaction to
missing out on the reunion. Perfectly understandable. But his denial
seems more serious than that. He has to know that his fellow
disciples are hearing him say: “I don't believe you. I don't
believe you are telling the truth. You're lying.” Grief or no
grief, they can't be happy with him, and he knows it. Christ has
established his mission on the power of testimony; that is, the
entire project of preaching the Good News depends on the ability of
his followers to bear witness to his life and works. To tell the
world about how Christ has changed their lives by bringing them into
right relationship with divine love. By denying Christ's appearance
among the disciples, Thomas is rejecting the very means of building
the Church that Christ himself proclaimed. Thomas is the modern
person standing against the Gospel-witness of the Church, demanding
empirical evidence for her claims. How do we respond to our own
Thomases?
Christ
responds to Thomas by appearing again – in the wounded,
post-resurrection flesh. He invites Thomas to touch his wounds and
says, “...do
not be unbelieving, but believe.”
Is this an option for us? Can we invite our Thomases to touch
Christ's wounds and believe? Well, not exactly like Christ does in
the Gospel, but we can bear witness to our own wounds and the healing
Christ gives us. We can show our Thomas the brokenness we offered to
Christ. We can show him our despair, our pride, our envy. We can show
him the times we chose against love and mercy and how Christ's love
and mercy brought us out of darkness into the light. We can show him
how we have been betrayed, rejected, ignored, and silenced. How we
stood in the crowd on Palm Sunday, cheering him on, and then screamed
for his death on Good Friday. How we deny him when we deny the least
of his. We can invite him into our doubts and denials and show him
how – in the larger divine plan – our demands for proof fall
short. We can even confess to smaller and larger betrayals of Christ
in our sin. And then bear witness to the forgiveness we receive when
we confess. At rock bottom, all we can do for our Thomases is show
them Christ as we've lived with him. From there, it's the HS's
mission to bring about a conversion of heart.
That's what we can do for the Thomases we encounter. What if we
ourselves are a Thomas? It happens. Maybe no one here is a Thomas all
the time...but there are times when believing is a battle. We're
asked to believe a host of incredible things. The historical,
physical reality of the Resurrection is perhaps the most incredible.
But I'm willing to bet that if we experience doubts or express
denials, it's not about the Big Dogmatic Stuff. It's about the
smaller stuff – have I really forgiven him/her? Am I really
forgiven? Is the HS really guiding me? Am I doing everything I need
to do to get to heaven? Does God really hear my prayers? When these
doubts and denials pop up – and they will! – remember God's
mercy. We're not here to provide entertainment for the HT. We're not
playing a cosmic game. We are given a purpose – to freely return to
God in love. We are given everything we need to make that happen.
Whatever happens here – good, bad, ugly – contributes to our
progress toward perfection in Christ. And all of it is fueled by
divine mercy. He knows our doubts. He says, “Do not be unbelieving
but believe.”
Follow
HancAquam or Subscribe ----->